Did Schlieffen Plan Fail Essay

Failure Of The Schlieffen Plan Essay

Failure of the Schlieffen Plan

The aim of the plan was to avoid having to fight two was at the same
time (France and Russia). The plan was devised by Alfred Von
Schlieffen. His plan was to attack France, not on the main border,
which was strongly fortified, but to attack through Belgium and circle
the Paris by going to the west of it, not east. He predicted this
should take 6 weeks leaving enough time to go to the eastern front at
Russia and fight there. The plan was very precise and accurate but
when it was put into action there were changes, which led to the
Germans failing to capture France.

The first change was made by Moltke (Schlieffen’s successor). He
decided that they would not go through Holland, but just go through
Belgium, hoping to keep Britain neutral. One of the main factors of
the plan was the speed. However, this slowed down everything as they
now only had one railway line to transport five large armies. Also,
they did not expect the resistance from Belgium. Although, Belgium was
not that strong, they delayed the Germans for 12 days at the fortress
at Liège. The Germans had to bring up the railway-mounted artillery.
The Belgians also stopped supplies and reinforcements, and destroyed
their railways.

One of the great ideas about the Schlieffen Plan was that the army
invading France was so large and strong. However, when Russia
recovered unexpectedly in 10 days (not six weeks as the Germans
expected) the German leaders worried and many troops were transported
to the Eastern front, weakening the blow to France. By now they were
very behind schedule.

The consequences were bad for the Germans. France was sending troops
to the frontier at the North and even more importantly, Britain had
joined the war. They had promised to protect Belgium (because they
were worried about being attacked on...

Loading: Checking Spelling

0%

Read more

Was the German defeat on the Western Front caused by the failure of the Schlieffen Plan?

2199 words - 9 pages After German foreign policy had caused the country to have hostile countries on either side - France and Russia - Germany needed a plan to win a war on two fronts. This plan was devised in the early twentieth century by Count Alfred von Schlieffen and then tinkered with fairly extensively by the younger Moltke right up until 1914. It is known as the Schlieffen...

What role did the BEF play in the failure of the Schlieffen plan

748 words - 3 pages The British expeditionary force or the BEF became involved in the war because of Belgium. The Germans decided to go through Belgium as part of the Schlieffen plan, and though they knew that the British might become involved...

The Failure of the Schlieffen Plan and Germany’s Defeat on the Western Front

2017 words - 8 pages The Failure of the Schlieffen Plan and Germany’s Defeat on the Western Front On November 11th, 1918, an armistice was signed declaring that the war to end all wars was over and that Germany had been defeated by the Allied powers. When the war began in the late months of 1914, Germany’s plan to win the war (the Schlieffen plan) failed. To what extent was the failure of this plan responsible for Germany’s defeat in the...

The Failure of the Schlieffen Plan and Its Effects on the German Defeat on the Western Front

1380 words - 6 pages The Failure of the Schlieffen Plan and Its Effects on the German Defeat on the Western Front By the spring of 1914, imperial Germany was spoiling for war. Germany’s leaders were determined to break up the Triple Entente of Britain, France & Russia that had isolated Germany in Europe & thwarted its territorial ambitions. And when Arch-Duke Franz Ferdinand was assassinated on June 28 1914 it gave Kaiser Wilhelm the reason to...

The Failure of Plan Colombia

3076 words - 12 pages Background Plan Colombia is a long-prevailing foreign aid package bestowed to the country of Colombia from the United States. This foreign aid package grants substantial financial assistance to Colombia, intending to fight the “War on Drugs” and to reduce the trafficking of narcoleptics, but there is a multitude of other factors and implications, both unintentional or indirect and intentional due to ulterior motives. To accomplish the goals of...

Exploring the Possibilities of a successful Schlieffen Plan (Germany's plan in WWI)

2848 words - 11 pages Germany Dictates the FutureExploring the Possible Results of a Successful Schlieffen PlanIan WesternInternational Relations - J BlockMR. THOMPSONDelbarton SchoolSeptember 25th, 2008World War I has...

The Reasons for the Schlieffen Plan

2545 words - 10 pages The Reasons for the Schlieffen Plan In this piece of coursework I will be investigating the actual reasons for the Schlieffen Plan due to the situation which the German government was in. I will talk of the harsh reality of the war and the situation all the countries involved in the war entered. I will also talk about the reasons why the Schlieffen Plan failed and the Germans were made to face a grim reality which was...

How the Schlieffen Plan was Meant to Work

2844 words - 11 pages How the Schlieffen Plan was Meant to Work When war was declared in August 1914, Germany was allied in "The Triple Alliance" with the Austro - Hungarian Empire and Italy. Britain, Russia and France were allied as "The Triple Entente." The alliance between Britain, France and Russia rendered Germany's geographical position a weakness, with France and Britain on it's Western Frontier, and Russia in the East. This meant...

Explain how the Schlieffen plan was meant to work: GCSE Coursework.

2290 words - 9 pages History Coursework - The First World War.Explain how the Schlieffen plan was meant to work.The Schlieffen plan was the strategy Germany planned to adopt in the event of a war in 1914. It was intended to bring a fast, effective victory for Germany, and was devised by Count Alfred von Schlieffen who was the Chief of the General...

The Failure of Chartism

848 words - 3 pages The Failure of Chartism For the chartist to have had a focus, they would all have to have had the same issues, and all held equal support for all 6 parts of the people’s charter, the paper behind the chartist movement. This was not the case; in many instances the people would only support something when it suited them, a knife and fork issue, this was the cause for the collapse in the movement. In source one it does say how people wanted...

The Failure of Reconstruction

770 words - 3 pages The Failure of ReconstructionIn 1863, the Emancipation Proclamation gave freedom to all of the blacks. However, the road to freedom for the blacks was still going to be a long one and would not start until after the end of the Civil War. The Reconstruction definitely failed in bringing social and economic equality to the blacks because of; the failure of the

The Schlieffen Plan was created by General Count Alfred von Schlieffen in December 1905. The Schlieffen Plan was the operational plan for a designated attack on France once Russia, in response to international tension, had started to mobilise her forces near the German border. The execution of the Schlieffen Plan led to Britain declaring war on Germany on August 4th, 1914.

In 1905, Schlieffen was chief of the German General Staff. Europe had effectively divided into two camps by this year – Germany, Austria and Italy (the Triple Alliance) on one side and Britain, France and Russia (the Triple Entente) on the other.

Schlieffen believed that the most decisive area for any future war in Europe would be in the western sector. Here, Schlieffen identified France as Germany’s most dangerous opponent. Russia was not as advanced as France in many areas and Schlieffen believed that Russia would take six weeks to mobilise her forces and that any possible fighting on the Russian-German border could be coped with by the Germans for a few weeks while the bulk of her forces concentrated on defeating France.

Schlieffen concluded that a massive and successful surprise attack against France would be enough to put off Britain becoming involved in a continental war. This would allow Germany time (the six weeks that Schlieffen had built into his plan) to transfer soldiers who had been fighting in the successful French campaign to Russia to take on the Russians.

Schlieffen also planned for the attack on France to go through Belgium and Luxemburg. Belgium had had her neutrality guaranteed by Britain in 1839 – so his strategy for success depended on Britain not supporting Belgium.

The Schlieffen Plan was revised as tension in Europe increased. However, the basic mechanics of it remained the same:

a devastating attack on France via Belgium as soon as Russia had announced her intention to mobilise.

a holding operation on the Russian/German border to be carried out if necessary and if required.

Germany had 6 weeks to defeat France.

Germany would then use her modernised rail system to move troops from the French operation to the Russian front.

Russia would then be attacked and defeated.

The Schlieffen Plan was daring but it had a number of glaring weaknesses:

The actions of Russia determined when Germany would have to start her attack on France even if she was ready or not.

It assumed that Russia would need six weeks to mobilise.

It assumed that Germany would defeat France in less than six weeks.

In fact, the attack in August 1914 nearly succeeded and was only defeated by the first Battle of the Marne. Poor communication between the frontline commanders and the army’s headquarters in Berlin did not help Moltke’s control of the campaign. Also the withdrawal of German troops in response to a higher than expected threat on the Russian front, meant that the Germans did not have the military clout that Schlieffen had built into his original plan. It was a plan that nearly succeeded but its success could only be measured by being 100% successful. France had to be defeated – and this did not happen. Schlieffen’s speedy attack and expected defeat of France never occurred – it’s failure did usher in the era of trench warfare that is so much linked to World War One.

Further Reading:

Invasion 1914: The Schlieffen Plan to the Battle of the Marne

Ian Senior

BUY NOW

 

 

Michael S Neiberg

BUY NOW

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *